Property Managers May Lie About Markups: What You Need to Know

Hey landlords! Have you ever noticed discrepancies in your property management bills, especially when it comes to repair and maintenance costs? Unfortunately, some property managers lie or mislead landlords about markups on repairs, taking advantage of the fact that many landlords don’t know the actual cost of materials or services. This unethical practice can drain your profits, and if you're not paying attention, you might end up overpaying significantly. If this sounds familiar, consider booking a Free Landlord Consultation to discuss how you can take control of your property management.

What Are Markups?

A markup is the amount added to the cost price of goods or services to cover overhead and profit. For example, if a contractor charges $200 to fix a plumbing issue, some property managers might add an additional percentage as their fee for coordinating the repair. While a small markup is often justified for administrative work, excessive or hidden markups can be unethical and cost you more than necessary.

Signs Your Property Manager May Be Lying About Markups

1. Lack of Transparency in Invoices
   If your property manager provides vague or generic invoices for repairs without itemized details, they may be hiding markups. Look for invoices that break down material costs, labor fees, and any administrative charges separately. If you’re not seeing these details, ask for them.

2. Inconsistent Repair Costs
   If repair costs seem unusually high or inconsistent, it could be a sign of excessive markups. For instance, a simple light fixture replacement that should cost around $50 might suddenly cost $200. Compare prices for similar jobs in your area to determine if you’re being overcharged.

3. Using Preferred Vendors Without Justification
   Some property managers work with specific contractors and service providers, sometimes because they receive kickbacks or inflated markups. If your property manager refuses to get multiple bids for repairs or insists on using their preferred vendor without justification, it could be a red flag.

How to Protect Yourself from Markup Lies

1. Request Multiple Bids
If your property manager is overseeing a repair or renovation, ask for multiple bids from different vendors. This helps ensure you’re getting a fair price for the job. If your property manager resists, it could be a sign that they’re inflating prices.

2. Require Detailed Invoices
Always request itemized invoices that break down labor costs, materials, and any additional fees. This transparency will allow you to compare the prices with industry standards and detect any unreasonable markups.

3. Set Markup Limits in Your Contract
When signing a contract with a property manager, clearly define the percentage of markup they are allowed to add to repair or maintenance work. This prevents surprises and ensures that they can’t take advantage of you with excessive fees.

4. Audit Your Expenses Regularly
Keep a close eye on your property expenses and review them monthly. If you notice a pattern of inflated costs or suspect that you’re being overcharged, it might be time to have a conversation with your property manager or consider switching to self-management.

Consider Self-Managing Your Property

If you're tired of dealing with hidden fees and dishonest property managers, self-managing your property might be the best option. By doing so, you’ll have full control over repairs, maintenance, and tenant interactions, allowing you to avoid unnecessary markups altogether. Tools like Zillow Rental Manager and TurboTenant can make the self-management process simple, even for first-time landlords.

• Tip: If you’re considering self-management but aren’t sure where to start, check out my Free Landlord Class to get the basics on how to successfully manage your rental properties.

FAQ: Dealing with Markups from Property Managers

Q: How much markup is reasonable for a property manager to charge?
A: Markups between 10-20% for coordinating repairs are fairly common in the property management industry. Anything significantly higher may be a red flag for unethical behavior.

Q: Can I challenge a property manager’s repair bill?
A: Absolutely. If you believe you’re being overcharged or lied to about costs, ask for itemized invoices and compare them with estimates from other vendors. Don’t hesitate to negotiate or dispute charges you find unreasonable.

Q: Should I switch to self-management if I can’t trust my property manager?
A: Self-management can save you money and give you more control. If your property manager is dishonest or unethical, switching to self-management or finding a more trustworthy manager could be a smart decision.

For more tips and resources, visit our website: Landlord Strategy.

Join Our Community

• Visit our website for free landlord resources: Landlord Strategy
• Get a Free Landlord Consultation: Free Consultation
• Follow us on Instagram: Landlord Strategy Instagram

Don’t let property managers take advantage of you with dishonest markups. If you suspect unethical behavior, take action to protect your investment and your profits. Schedule your Free Landlord Consultation today to discuss your concerns and explore self-management options.